Issues with improper gear offering

[bolenarcher]

I can't post the screen shots right now, but I am concerned about the gear guide. I just bought it and hopped on my 85 Enhancement Shaman. Upon loading him up before heading to work, I clicked on the gear guide and was shocked to see the guide telling me to run a dungeon and replace my 410 back piece with a 378 back piece. The only thing the 378 had higher was +138 crit, which is the lowest priority stat. It wants me to lose 80 Agility and I don't remember the other stats, but it was shocking to say the least.

I scrolled down and in the off-hand slot, the guide is telling me to run a dungeon to get an item held in the off hand that has intellect on it and right now I have the one handed axe from DW equipped.

I just downloaded the guide today, so I have the newest version installed.

[cabby]

Can you please let me know what item you have equipped and what item it recommends for replacement? Just the names of the items is fine because I can look them up to see the stats. It might just be that the way we score items would be the reason or it might be a bug in the system but we can't know which without knowing the items.

[bolenarcher]

1. (Equipped) Stormstout Drink Napkin ---> (recommended) Cloak of the Banshee Queen
2. (Equipped) No'Kaled, the Elements of Death ---> (recommended) Bottle of Potent Potables

[cabby]

Those are definitely not correct. The next time you see a wrong suggestion like this could you please click on the little gear icon on the gear recommendation pop-up (lower right corner), generate a bug report, zip it up and post it? This will allow the dev team to see more information for what is happening at that exact moment to find the problem and get it fixed.

[roblinz_10]

incorrect gear suggestion

Those are definitely not correct. The next time you see a wrong suggestion like this could you please click on the little gear icon on the gear recommendation pop-up (lower right corner), generate a bug report, zip it up and post it? This will allow the dev team to see more information for what is happening at that exact moment to find the problem and get it fixed.

ace: Orc Class: WARLOCK Spec: Destruction Level: 21.27 Faction: Horde

Current item: #56627 [Labor Camp Frock]
Suggested item: #59566 [Robe of Shame]
-2 Intellect
-1 Stamina
-2 Critical Strike
-12 Armor

20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] Stat analysis: 56627 [Labor Camp Frock] type: Cloth slot: INVTYPE_ROBE ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] + ILEVEL 21.0, sub weighted ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] + 5.0 INTELLECT: * 20.0 = 100.0 ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] + 2.0 CRIT_RATING: * 12.0 = 24.0 ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] = 124 ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] Stat analysis: 59566 [Robe of Shame] type: Cloth slot: INVTYPE_ROBE ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] + ILEVEL 16.0, sub weighted ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] + 3.0 INTELLECT: * 20.0 = 60.0 ()
20:16:57.318.319> [itemscore] = 60 ()


Current Gear
ChestSlot - [Labor Camp Frock]#56627 scored: 124
WristSlot - [Bracers of Angry Mutterings]#59578 scored: 129
BackSlot - [Tumultuous Cloak of the Sorcerer]#51994 scored: 250
MainHandSlot - [Cookie's Stirring Stick]#66028 scored: 60
Finger0Slot - [Lavishly Jeweled Ring]#1156 scored: 124
SecondaryHandSlot - [Out-of-Date Manual]#59547 scored:
HeadSlot - [Safari Hat]#92738 scored: 0
ShoulderSlot - [Slime-Encrusted Pads]#6461 scored: 267

Possible Upgrades
ChestSlot - [Robe of Shame]#59566 scored: 204

20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] PLAYER_EQUIPMENT_CHANGED (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] Finding current equipped. (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] In slot HeadSlot, [Safari Hat] got scored at 0 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] In slot ShoulderSlot, [Slime-Encrusted Pads] got scored at 267 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] In slot BackSlot, [Tumultuous Cloak of the Sorcerer] got scored at 250 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] In slot ChestSlot, [Labor Camp Frock] got scored at 124 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] In slot WristSlot, [Bracers of Angry Mutterings] got scored at 129 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.217> [autoequip] In slot HandsSlot, [Gold-Flecked Gloves] got scored at 237 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.218> [autoequip] In slot WaistSlot, [Painstakingly Crafted Belt] got scored at 137 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)
20:16:37.212.218> [autoequip] In slot LegsSlot, [Leggings of the Traveling Medic] got scored at 256 (ItemScore.lua:725ebug)

[cabby]

I've added that one to the list for the dev team to look at.

[roblinz_10]

thanks. i didnt know how to zip it up so i just copy pasted as much of it as i could.

[cabby]

What you have there is good. It lets the devs see the discrepancy between the item's score and the 'supposed' score when it's being suggested.