UPDATE: Reloading the UI after setting stat weights seems to fix the problem. This isn't mentioned on the item scoring screen, and other addons like Pawn don't require a reload. I suggest adding some sort of mention of this on the item scoring screen.
I have both Pawn and Zygor's installed and I have been using SimulationCraft to calculate stat weights for my characters. Pawn shows the correct score for each item based on my stat weights (which I have calculated by hand to prove), and despite importing the same string into Zygor's as I have to Pawn (with the exact same stat weights), Zygor's recommends different gear in almost every instance.
I went to generate a report about the suggestion being wrong and I noticed something. In the report it showed a full calculation of the gear and it was using completely different stat weights from the ones I had set in the settings panel.
Here is the stat weight string I imported into Zygor's and Pawn for a warlock I'm leveling:
( Pawn: v1: "Mortuarty-Affliction": Class=Warlock, Spec=Affliction, Intellect=6.84, CritRating=4.27, HasteRating=4.71, MasteryRating=4.68, Versatility=4.2 )
And here are the calculations in the error report:
LOGS
ItemScore calculating: [Seal of House Farondis] (item:132911::::::::103:265:512:11:1:1792:101:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 392.0 HASTE: * 6.8 = 2661.7
+ 261.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 2359.4
+ 294.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 5021
ItemScore calculating: [Signet of the Watcher's Guile] (item:121560::::::::103:265:512:11:1:767:103:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 453.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 4095.1
+ 236.0 VERSATILITY: * 3.0 = 717.4
+ 311.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 4812
As you can see the weight for haste is 6.8 instead of 4.71, mastery is 9.0 instead of 4.68, and versatility is 3.0 instead of 4.2. These weights are not even proportionate to the weights I've entered as haste should be higher than mastery for the simulation I did for my level. If I go into the settings, however, I see the custom stat weights I entered and not the ones the addon is using.
Below is the full report from the item comparison. One other unrelated error in the report below I want to point out is the undead race is called the Forsaken not the Scourge. The Scourge were the Lich King's minions.
Zygor Guides Viewer v6.1.17516
Race: Scourge Class: WARLOCK Spec: Affliction Level: 103.79 Faction: Horde
Suggested item: [Seal of House Farondis] item:132911::::::::103:265:512:11:1:1792:101:::
Current item: [Signet of the Watcher's Guile] item:121560::::::::103:265:512:11:1:767:103:::
Current Gear
ChestSlot - [Leywalker Robe]#121435 scored: 6068
WristSlot - [Leywalker Wristwraps]#121444 scored: 3377
Trinket1Slot - [Valiana's Secret Recipe]#121489 scored: 4494
BackSlot - [Royal Apothecary Drape]#121488 scored: 3582
Trinket0Slot - [Accolade of the Banshee Queen]#138776 scored: 3002
MainHandSlot - [Ulthalesh, the Deadwind Harvester]#128942 scored: 2035057
HeadSlot - [Black Rose Hood]#129302 scored: 5114
Finger0Slot - [Signet of the Watcher's Guile]#121560 scored: 4812
LegsSlot - [Gilnean Fleece Pantaloons]#138852 scored: 4961
FeetSlot - [Leywalker Treads]#121420 scored: 4590
WaistSlot - [Leywalker Waistwrap]#121441 scored: 4508
HandsSlot - [Runespeaker's Gloves]#134554 scored: 4189
NeckSlot - [Psychotic Scholar's Chain]#121484 scored: 5321
ShoulderSlot - [Black Rose Amice]#139916 scored: 3204
Finger1Slot - [Band of Ingression]#129171 scored: 5044
Possible Upgrades
HeadSlot - [Combatant's Halo]#132901 scored: 5414
Finger0Slot - [Seal of House Farondis]#132911 scored: 5021
ShoulderSlot - [Starlance Amice]#138824 scored: 3622
LOGS
ItemScore calculating: [Seal of House Farondis] (item:132911::::::::103:265:512:11:1:1792:101:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 392.0 HASTE: * 6.8 = 2661.7
+ 261.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 2359.4
+ 294.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 5021
ItemScore calculating: [Signet of the Watcher's Guile] (item:121560::::::::103:265:512:11:1:767:103:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 453.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 4095.1
+ 236.0 VERSATILITY: * 3.0 = 717.4
+ 311.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 4812
I have both Pawn and Zygor's installed and I have been using SimulationCraft to calculate stat weights for my characters. Pawn shows the correct score for each item based on my stat weights (which I have calculated by hand to prove), and despite importing the same string into Zygor's as I have to Pawn (with the exact same stat weights), Zygor's recommends different gear in almost every instance.
I went to generate a report about the suggestion being wrong and I noticed something. In the report it showed a full calculation of the gear and it was using completely different stat weights from the ones I had set in the settings panel.
Here is the stat weight string I imported into Zygor's and Pawn for a warlock I'm leveling:
( Pawn: v1: "Mortuarty-Affliction": Class=Warlock, Spec=Affliction, Intellect=6.84, CritRating=4.27, HasteRating=4.71, MasteryRating=4.68, Versatility=4.2 )
And here are the calculations in the error report:
LOGS
ItemScore calculating: [Seal of House Farondis] (item:132911::::::::103:265:512:11:1:1792:101:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 392.0 HASTE: * 6.8 = 2661.7
+ 261.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 2359.4
+ 294.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 5021
ItemScore calculating: [Signet of the Watcher's Guile] (item:121560::::::::103:265:512:11:1:767:103:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 453.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 4095.1
+ 236.0 VERSATILITY: * 3.0 = 717.4
+ 311.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 4812
As you can see the weight for haste is 6.8 instead of 4.71, mastery is 9.0 instead of 4.68, and versatility is 3.0 instead of 4.2. These weights are not even proportionate to the weights I've entered as haste should be higher than mastery for the simulation I did for my level. If I go into the settings, however, I see the custom stat weights I entered and not the ones the addon is using.
Below is the full report from the item comparison. One other unrelated error in the report below I want to point out is the undead race is called the Forsaken not the Scourge. The Scourge were the Lich King's minions.
Zygor Guides Viewer v6.1.17516
Race: Scourge Class: WARLOCK Spec: Affliction Level: 103.79 Faction: Horde
Suggested item: [Seal of House Farondis] item:132911::::::::103:265:512:11:1:1792:101:::
Current item: [Signet of the Watcher's Guile] item:121560::::::::103:265:512:11:1:767:103:::
Current Gear
ChestSlot - [Leywalker Robe]#121435 scored: 6068
WristSlot - [Leywalker Wristwraps]#121444 scored: 3377
Trinket1Slot - [Valiana's Secret Recipe]#121489 scored: 4494
BackSlot - [Royal Apothecary Drape]#121488 scored: 3582
Trinket0Slot - [Accolade of the Banshee Queen]#138776 scored: 3002
MainHandSlot - [Ulthalesh, the Deadwind Harvester]#128942 scored: 2035057
HeadSlot - [Black Rose Hood]#129302 scored: 5114
Finger0Slot - [Signet of the Watcher's Guile]#121560 scored: 4812
LegsSlot - [Gilnean Fleece Pantaloons]#138852 scored: 4961
FeetSlot - [Leywalker Treads]#121420 scored: 4590
WaistSlot - [Leywalker Waistwrap]#121441 scored: 4508
HandsSlot - [Runespeaker's Gloves]#134554 scored: 4189
NeckSlot - [Psychotic Scholar's Chain]#121484 scored: 5321
ShoulderSlot - [Black Rose Amice]#139916 scored: 3204
Finger1Slot - [Band of Ingression]#129171 scored: 5044
Possible Upgrades
HeadSlot - [Combatant's Halo]#132901 scored: 5414
Finger0Slot - [Seal of House Farondis]#132911 scored: 5021
ShoulderSlot - [Starlance Amice]#138824 scored: 3622
LOGS
ItemScore calculating: [Seal of House Farondis] (item:132911::::::::103:265:512:11:1:1792:101:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 392.0 HASTE: * 6.8 = 2661.7
+ 261.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 2359.4
+ 294.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 5021
ItemScore calculating: [Signet of the Watcher's Guile] (item:121560::::::::103:265:512:11:1:767:103:: type: Miscellaneous slot: INVTYPE_FINGER in slot: INVTYPE_FINGER
Tooltip: unknown?
MULTIPLER 1.0
+ 453.0 MASTERY: * 9.0 = 4095.1
+ 236.0 VERSATILITY: * 3.0 = 717.4
+ 311.0 STAMINA: * 0.0 = 0.0
= 4812
Comment