Wrong Gear Reward Advised

[Snigglepoo]

Got another on my Fury Warrior.

Quest: The Root of the Corruption

Suggested: http://www.wowhead.com/item=65824 (Int, Stm, Spirit cape)

Should have suggested: http://www.wowhead.com/item=65822

What I have at turn in: http://www.wowhead.com/item=61463

Comparison of the two: http://www.wowhead.com/compare?items=65822;61463&l=84

At this point I have turned off the auto-select quest reward on all my characters, and would suggest anyone who is looking to have upgrades from questing do the same. Zygor selected a bad upgrade on one of my alts, and Blizzard GM will not swap out quest rewards if you get the wrong one.

I keep the quest reward advisor on though and manually select the items. Takes a few seconds more, but I am then sure any error in final selection will be on my part and not because of the addon.

Until these are fixed Zygor may want to put a a warning note next to that option or something because at this time it does say "no known issue, but may not be perfect" in the tooltip. However, there is something more than it not being perfect.

[Snigglepoo]

Quest: Missing Parts on my Fury Warrior

Suggestion: http://www.wowhead.com/item=63926

Should have suggested: http://www.wowhead.com/item=63925

What I have at turn in: http://www.wowhead.com/item=65834

Comparison of the two: http://www.wowhead.com/compare?items=63925;65834&l=84

Last two the only improvement of the old pieces would be crit. It may be getting stuck on that stat and not taking into consideration the improvement of the 5 other stats plus item level.

Sorry it's not. Just suggested these (http://www.wowhead.com/item=63903) and it's a -114 crit.


Maybe in cases like (in higher levels) have it state something like reforge A stat for B stat.

[cabby]

The gear suggestions don't even consider reforging possibilities so I'm pretty sure that's not affecting it at all.

[Snigglepoo]

The gear suggestions don't even consider reforging possibilities so I'm pretty sure that's not affecting it at all.

Yeah, I know it doesn't. It was a suggestion that if the addon is (or will be) going by a stat priority for the class/spec, a feature that could be considered for higher levels (once you can reforge) is to "suggest" best reforging on the item if the stats on the item are not ideal.

Similar to how Reforgerade or Ask Mr. Robot works.

Something like:

reforgesuggestion.jpg
(Yes, I know this item doesn't have Mastery)

[cabby]

Definitely something for the dev team to think about once they figure out the current problem.